Thursday, 30 September 1999

Inda -Tec 99: Atlanta - Sept 21st -23rd 1999




Jeff Dugan of Fibre Innovation Technology Inc. on Bicomponent Fibres

Conventional splittable fibres are made from (say) 8 segments of nylon and 8 segments of PET in a "pie-wedge" or "Citrus" configuration. The two different polymers have a low affinity for each other and therefore split easily into microfibres when stressed. They are used for synthetic suedes and leathers, wipes and filters. Problems with this long-established variety included difficult (2 step) dyeing needed for the textile end-uses, a tendency for nylon to fade easily, and to offer inferior chemical stability for some filters or indeed, some wipes.

To solve these problems, FIT were investigating fibre shape effects and different polymers. Round fibres with their mimimum surface/volume ratio had the least appropriate shape for splitting and this placed greater demands on using very different polymers in alternating segments.

  • Flat fibres made up of alternating polymers across the width were the easiest to split.
  • Y-shaped fibres with limb-tips made from different polymer from the core were easily cardable, harder to split, but much better than round fibre.
  • The segmented X-shape was a good compromise between flat and Y. (but in questions he admitted this was theory: the fibre had not been made.)
  • Tubular round fibres with a citrus configuration were more splittable than a solid round fibre.

With shape adjusted to reduce the demands on polymer incompatibility, one could contemplate the ideal all polyester or all polyolefin splittables.

  • For a start, the problems caused by nylon could be minimised simply by minimising the nylon fraction in a round citrus fibre. Nylon could be used to do no more than isolate the polyester segments from one another.
  • Using the renewable, crop-based Poly-lactic acid polyester (PLA) instead of nylon gave a surprisingly good all-polyester citrus fibre. The aliphatic PLA with its helical crystal structure has a very different surface energy to the aromatic, linear crystallised PET, and splits from it easily. Here the PLA gave other advantages related to its inherent absorbency, dyeability and comfort, all this without significant loss of strength, resilience or economy c.f. nylon.
  • Poly-methyl pentene (PMP) is a true polyolefin with chemical properties between PP and PE but melting at 240 oC. It splits from PP readily and makes a technically superior all-polyolefin citrus fibre. It's high cost (~$4/lb) is a problem which can be minimised by using it as no more than a coating on the PP segments.

A PP/poly acrylonitrile (PAN) splittable fibre looks both practicable and surprisingly advantageous:

  • BP's "Amlon" thermoplastic acrylic is cheaper than PMP and gives an excellent splittablity/chemical stability balance with PP.
  • PP and PAN are at opposite ends of the triboelectric series and develop opposite charges in needling. This give a more permanent electret effect than is possible with just PP where the opposite charges are on opposite sides of the same fibre.

Micro-Binder fibres can be made by having polymers with widely differing melt temperature:

  • PET/PE citrus fibres can be split in hydroentanglement and thermally bonded. The PE micro-fibres, intimately dispersed among the non-bonding PET fibres give many small areas of bonding and a nonwoven with an unusually good strength/softness balance.
  • PMP/PP citrus fibres would have thermal bondability with even better chemical resistance.

Elastomeric Splittable Fibres arise from segmenting PP or nylon and a thermoplastic polyurethane:

  • These had excellent chemical resistance and could be split using heat alone.
  • Because the spinning process orients and crystallises the PP and not the PU, the heating causes bulking and yields a self-bulking yarn for textile uses. However in staple form, the PU makes them hard to card.
  • If a Y-shaped fibre with a PU centre and nylon tips is made, carding is straightforward, and the fibre still splits spontaneously to give a high bulk nonwoven on heating.

Wet-laying splittable fibres is of course possible, but the dramatic increase in length/diameter ratio as the fibres split means that they have to be cut very short.

This FIT paper dealt only with re-engineering the pie-wedge or citrus section fibres. Similar thinking is already being applied to concentric and sea-island bicomponents.

Prof. Abhiraman of Georgia Tech on the Fundamentals of Polymer Extrusion


If you spin and anneal fast enough in a spun-bond or melt-blown process, even the unstretched fibres will crystallise to give strong high-modulus products. For instance the normally amorphous random copolymer of PET and polyethylene isophthalate, when spun at 6000m/minute with rapid annealing gives a highly birefringent crystalline fibre as evidenced by X-ray crystallograhy. Also, melt blowing PP from dope at 240 oC, with high veolcity air at 177 oC gives crystalline melt-blown microfibres. (This interesting lecture was unavailable in hard-copy and accompanied by minimalist overheads which the author had no intention of sharing with members of the audience.)

Professor Charles Beatty ( University of Florida ) on Polymeric Alloys


Insight into the growing possibility of making valuable products from post-consumer plastic waste, (but not available in print.)

The very properties of incompatibility necessary in splittable bicomponents prevented mixed polymers from being recycled into usable fibres or sheets. The problem lay with the molten blend being a collection of phase-separated domains with little interfacial adhesion. The solution was to reduce the size of these domains by more vigorus mixing and to increase the interfacial adhesion by grafting on reactive groups to bond the dissimilar polymers together. This was now being in a twin-screw extruder-reactor where the molten polymers were mixed and injected with the chemicals needed to achieve in-situ grafting. Maleic anhydride for condensation coupling or free-radical precursors were used to attach graft-compatible side groups to each polymer. These then reacted together in the extruder.

  • Trials with this equipment had successfully made PVC/PP, PVC/PE and PP/PE alloys extrudable as interconnected phases rather than as discreet domains.
  • The approach could also be used to form a PVC skin on PP. At 20% PVC or more in the blend, PVC accumulates at the surface of the PP due to the "surface excess" phenomena, and is firmly attached by the grafting. Could this be a way to make bicomponents with better dyeing and FR properties?
  • The reactive extrusion of the PP/PE mixture gave an almost ten-fold improvement in impact strength compared with normal extrusion of the same mixture.
  • SEM's showed a polystyrene/HDPE/polymethyl methacrylate mixture where the interface between domains appeared to contain micro-fibre bonds between the dissimilar polymers.
  • Polyester/PP alloys with useful mechanical properties heralded the recycling of the ubiquitous polyester pile, polypropylene backed carpet.

Dale Gregory (Consultant) on 30 years experience in Improving Melt-Spun Fibres.


He had just retired from Eastman. His rather theoretical paper led to the conclusion that further PET fibre improvements will result from the quest for ever greater uniformity of orientation per filament and the resulting denier per filament. This could be attained by reductions in variability of melt viscosity, temperature and dwell time within the spin-pack. Outside the spin-pack, along-the-filament variations could be reduced by developing less variable quenching systems.

Dennis Tavernetti (BBA). Keynote Address:"Failure: The Mother of Invention"


He sought to demonstrate that failure, as part of a systematic "trial and error" development process, is essential to progress. With the nonwovens industry in a period of consolidation, with supply exceeding demand, with selling prices and margins falling, it was natural to move to reduce costs. However if investment and R&D were cut, the nonwovens industry would fall into the same trap as the US textile industry.

The correct response was to try to add more value through invention, and to make sure that the inventions provided real tangible benefits without adding more cost than value. The perceived value much loved by "Marketing" led at best to too many "inventions", and hence high patenting and marketing costs for products which would only ever have a short life-cycle before the consumer realised they offered little real value. Edison did not develop electric lighting without numerous failures.

It was important to recognise a failure, to stop wasting time and money pushing ahead on products with dubious tangible benefits and to redirect the limited development resources to more fruitful areas.

Panel Discussion


Dennis also presented a review of the US nonwoven scene for the introduction to the panel discussion:

  • The only growth in North America diaper sales was in Mexico (13% p.a.).
  • Nonwoven use per diaper had increased due to core-wrap, acquisition and distribution layers, and cloth-like backsheet developments.
  • However while demand for these coverstock-type fabrics was running at 200,000 tonnes/year, the supply was 270,000 tonnes/year.
  • Card/latex was massively oversubscribed in 1998 despite its resurgence in acquisition layers.
  • Card/thermal was 30% oversubscribed but had special properties (more textile-like than spunbond) and was expected to be back in balance by 2003.

Frank Harris, CEO of Fibre Innovation Technology gave his view of the next 5 years.


  • He saw further industry consolidation but expected an upsurge of new small companies making unique high-value products.
  • Textile replacement would gather pace, with home furnishings and automotive textiles being vulnerable to hydroentangled nonwovens.
  • Alliances between nonwoven and textile companies could be expected as the textile industry registered the new opportunities for nonwovens.
  • Environmentally driven products and processes would gain ground, but global competition would prevent any significant increases in raw material prices.
  • In the fibre industry he saw increasing demands for bicomponent fibres (F.I.T.'s speciality) and not just for thermal bonding.
  • He was expecting 10-15% p.a. growth for these fibres mainly in the personal care market and in automotive products.
  • Perhaps surprisingly, he saw the emergence of 2 major new fibre types, both polyesters: PTT (poly-trimethylene terephthalate) and crop-based PLA (Poly Lactic Acid). Both would gain ground in conventional textiles before becoming available in nonwovens.
  • Short-cut fibres for airlaying (3-4mm) would grow at 15-20% over the 5 year period.
  • Spunbonded nonwovens based on the newer fine denier, bicomponent, multibeam technologies would grow.
  • Splittable fibres would be used in needling to make new home-furnishing and automotive "textiles".

Lee Sullivan of Freudenberg-Spunweb


expected to see 30,000 tonnes of lightweight PET spunbonds produced in the USA in 2000, and a further 4000 tonnes to be imported. Overcapacity was evident in PP spunbonds, and while PET was broadly in balance, the two new announcements amounting to an extra 6000-8000 tpa capacity would create an imbalance. Heavyweight PET spunbonds, especially in the roofing sector, were facing strong competition from needlefelts and it was in this market that overcapacity was most evident.

Tom West of Dupont Nonwovens


pointed out that sustained growth over many years only arises from constant re-invention of the company. Dupont had been an explosives company in the 19 th C., a chemicals and energy company in the 20 th and was expected to become a Chemistry, Biology and "Knowledge intensive solutions" company in the 21 st C. Furthermore while the 20 th C. had relied heavily on raw materials from oil, next century would see a switch into raw materials from agricultural crops (PLA again).

Like Dennis he was concerned that the US nonwovens industry was not reinvesting enough in new technology and R&D to stand up to the global competition now emerging. Like Frank, he saw growth opportunities in textile replacement and felt elastic nonwovens could hold the key to faster progress. (N.B. Dupont's "Xymid": Lycra overstitching of a spunlaced nonwoven.)

  • How much is Dupont investing in R&D?

A. 5-6% of sales overall and up to 10% in new technology areas.

Q. Why was crop-based polylactic acid figuring relatively strongly in these forecasts?

A. The panel listed:

  • It has a cost-point between nylon and polyester.
  • It has a very cotton-like handle.
  • It is easily dyeable, and has excellent UV stability
  • It is from a renewable resource.
  • It is inherently absorbent and comfortable next to the skin.
  • Dow-Cargill are contemplating a several hundred million pound per year plant.
  • At 300million lbs/year capacity, the costs will be below $2/lb.
  • How big a role would crop-based polymers play in the Dupont of ten years hence?

A. We already have a pilot plant.

Q. Why the investments in China?

A. Not for short-term profit. China might just become the world's largest nonwoven market and being in at the start was good strategy.

Michael Tierney of Morgan, Lewis & Bockius: "Protect yourself!"


US patent law sets certain requirements for the patentability of an invention and the information needed for a patent application. Familiarity with these requirements is important to avoid "patent pitfalls" and to provide sound patent protection for strategic research and development. This presentation gave an overview of the property rights provided by a patent, discussed the standard for patentabililty, and provided various strategies for obtaining commercially effective patents.

"Measuring and Predicting Planar Absorbency Rates", by Bernie Miller of TRI


In Bernie's eyes, Washburn had earned his fame by simply substituting La Place's equation into Poisseules equation. Bernie used the equation, suitably corrected for the effects of gravity, to show that whenever porous structures start to wick fluid, those with the larger pores will always outperform those with the smaller pores. However, past a certain wicking height and time, the smaller pore structures overtake and continue to absorb faster and further than the larger pore structures. So, conclusions drawn from wicking tests over say 2 minutes could be the opposite of those from tests conducted over an hour.

Ram Shet of Technology Forecast Int. ( Neenah ) on the importance of proteins in Femcare:


Both soluble proteins and glycoproteins have a negative impact on the performance of feminine hygiene products. Utilizing the knowledge of protein-polymer interaction in biomedical products, a large increase in absorbency can be achieved by engineering the molecular architecture of superabsorbents in feminine hygiene pads

  • Real urine contains enzymes which breakdown CMC superabsorbents so that even products with good retention under pressure with saline are degraded by urine.
  • Real Menses contain proteins which spontaneously absorb onto any hydrophobic surface. It sticks due to charge, polarity, and increasing hydrophobicity as the protein unfolds.
  • Hard proteins (lysoyme, ribonuclease) absorb under all conditions onto hydrophobic surfaces, but onto hydrophilics if electrostatically attracted.
  • They can be displaced by soft proteins (myoglobin, albumin) which have lower structural stability and unfold much more readily. They absorb despite some hydrophilic dehydration and electrostatic replusion.
  • Whenever blood contacts a foreign material, it coats it with plasma proteins which then dominate all subsequent absorbtion.
  • Experiments studying the interaction of amphoteric polyamide membranes (made from 19.8 micron particles) with Bovine Serum Albumin (BSA) were described
  • The membranes were treated with 0.1 Molar NaOH for times ranging from 5 to 30 minutes to give samples with differing carboxyl levels.
  • Absorbtion of BSA onto the membranes is reduced by the increasing negative charge due to carboxyls.
  • Absorbency of menses on cross-linked polyacrylic acid polymers can be improved by the use of surfactants, amido compounds, organic and inorganic salts.
  • If SAP's are neutralised with K + rather than Na + and to a lower degree of neutralisation, blood absorbency is substantially increased. (The opposite is true of saline absorbency)
  • K + neutralised SAP's give dramatic increases in free swell at 5 minutes immersion but slightly less free swell at 30 mins (c.f. Na +)
  • K + SAP's from the relatively hydrophobic methacrylic acid monomer absorb blood faster (twice the volume in 5 mins) and have only slightly lower free swell at 60 mins (c.f. K + polyacrylic acid SAP's)
  • Kimberly Clark's US Patents 5,241,009 and 5,346,485 (1993-4) were referenced.

Amy Morgan of Fibervisions on Visualising Fibre Finish:


Finish distribution is a key parameter in the absorbency, processability and uniformity of roll goods.

  • Finishes are applied to lubricate, to control fibre-to-metal and fibre-to-fibre friction and to allow liquid management.
  • Finish is applied to PP before and after crimping, the latter to make up for losses caused by heat and steam in crimping.
  • Finish uniformity has proved very hard to quantify with none of the following methods being satisfactory:
  • Web uniformity measurement on the assumption that more even webs result from more even finish. (effected by many factors other than finish)
  • Dynamic absorbtion testing. (multiple water drop test on webs: not good for fast absorbing fibres.)
  • Tow wicking rate and pattern. (Not good for absorbent fibres)
  • Single filament wicking - contact angle measurement. (too small a sample)
  • Friction testing on a running tow. (factors other than finish can effect it)
  • Optical microscopy to see the finish globules. (Better for hydrophobics than hydrophilics)
  • Microfluorimetry, but the need to add fluorescent tracers to the finish is often impractical on production machines.
  • Conventional SEM: sample preparation and high voltages can remove finish globules.
  • Replica SEM: taking a silicone cast of the fibre surface. (Too fiddly and can remove finish also.)
  • Environmental SEM: too expensive.

The proposed solution was not totally convincing but the pictures from the technique were excellent.

She had used a "state of the art" R.J.Lee PSM-300 which is much cheaper than environmental SEM, uses low accelerating voltage, and does not need the sample to be in high vacuum. After easy sample preparation, the finish droplets are clearly visible. Samples taken through processing show the finish being smeared out over the fibre.

In response to questions, she confirmed positive identification of the finish droplets using elemental X-ray spectra on the drops as seen, and that she had done no work on cellulosics.

Airlaid Composites and Superabsorbent Polymers: by Edgar Herrmann, Stockhausen.


Absorbent polymers are one key component in absorbent airlaid cores. By varying SAP types in "modular based constructions", the targeted end-use products can be simply achieved through a combination of different prefabricated constituents. These experiments with their SXM4750 and SXM9100 SAP's in 32 different three-layer composites furnished predictable overall conclusions:

  • The more permeable SAP gave the fastest acquisition and transport.
  • Diaper rewet is better for the most retentive SAP.
  • Densification of air-laid pulp/SAP composites slows their acquisition rate.
  • Densification improves rewet.

Conclusions regarding the layer combinations and mixtures of SAP were less easy to draw, but were said to demonstrate ways of solving individual design problems.

Dr Thomas Fechter of Fleissner on High Pressure Spunlacing


The application of high-pressure hydroentangling systems has opened up new possibilities for product optimization and development.

  • He showed photo's of two of Fleissers installations:
  • A 1.8 metre 5 step (4 drums and a belt) machine with 7 injectors to make 600gsm fabrics.
  • A 2.5 metre 3 step (2 drums and a belt) machine with 7 injectors for lightweights.
  • The water system is cleaned by froth floatation followed by self cleaning sand filters. The sand filters are static-bed unlike (he said) the more fluidised system which Perfojet found leaked fine sand and eroded jet strips at an alarming rate.
  • The froth floatation unit was said to remove fibre finish from the water system as well as fibre debris.
  • They need to use antifoams to prevent foam from some finishes disrupting the sand filters.
  • They use one piston pump per injector.
  • They reduce the hole size to 0.1mm for heavyweights (>200gsm) to avoid flooding.
  • Graphs of strength v speed showed strength reductions in the 100 to 200m/min range which could be corrected by pressure increases. (Below 100 m/min, speed and strength were unrelated.)
  • On heavyweights, an energy input of 200 KW/metre is regarded as the economic limit for HE. Above this, the economics favour needlepunching.
  • The key area for development was nozzle design and perfecting the hole profile to get longer coherent columns of water. (no fanning out)
  • They are working with water additives to improve entanglement efficiency. (Viscosifiers??)
  • They predict being able to install a 5.5metre wide line working at 600 m/min and 600 bar for spunbond. (n.b. This would make spunbonds much more textile-like and could be regarded as the two-dimensional analogue of yarn texturising.)
  • He commented that jet life on viscose was 6 months compared to 1 year on polyester. This was due to 1 micron particles coming off the viscose. Questioning him afterwards revealed that he was unaware of the difference between matt and bright and didn't know which lustre had been used. (The particles were most likely titania from matt viscose being damaged by too high a pressure)

Steve Russell of Leeds Univ. on Structurally-Engineered Air Laid Webs


They had used a high speed camera to observe fibre motion in the 20-year old Kroyer machine donated by BFF. The only interesting observation was that as the web thickness increased, an increasing number of fibres tended to stick vertically in those already laid down. The fact that he had used straight rather than crimped fibres made the observations less valuable.

Advanced Airlaid Composites Based on Superabsorbent Fibers by Ian Cheyne of Camelot.


He showed how product and process simplification coupled with "a superior absorbent fibre" (Fiberdri™) can yield lower cost, more absorbent and more flexible feminine hygiene products. The 3-layer Fiberdri™ pad was compared with 3 commercial pads for cost, acquisition time, capacity, retention, spreading and rewet using saline, synthetic menstrual fluid and bovine blood:

  • The air-laid composite with fibrous SAP had a materials cost no more than the lowest cost commercial product of comparable performance. (he said)
  • Potential for lower capital and operating costs had been demonstrated.
  • Potential existed for distribution cost savings. (30% thinner product)
  • Despite lighter weight, the fibrous composite was ranked first for absorbency
  • The fibrous product was more fabric-like in texture than the competitors.
  • SA Fibres give more uniform air-laying than powders, with less dusting, migration and fallout, better performance on compression and better wet integrity.

Karla Garner of Kosa on Bicomponent PET for airlaying:


They had studied the effects of fibre denier (3, 15 and 32), shape (round, trilobal, pentalobal and High Void), and concentration (12-52%) on the tensiles, bulk and compression resistance of air-laid pulp webs. 6mm fibres with 8-10 crimps/inch had been used throughout.

  • 12% PET doubles the total capacity, doubles the web thickness and nearly doubles the wicking height.
  • 15 dpf appeared to be the optimum denier.
  • Wicking improves with shape: round
  • Absorbency decreases with PET contents above 12%.
  • The more PET fibres (numerically) the weaker the web. (32 denier had least effect at any given concentration.)

Henning Skov-Jensen on the prospects for an Air-Lay Super-Site:


He defined a super-site as a single plant air-laying 100,000 tonnes per year and festooning the output to feed on-site diaper production. The air layer would have a calender to densify the output to 0.4 gms/cc and bond it. He thought it possible that the super site could even be built at a pulp-mill to achieve further integration.

The paper was notable for it's comprehensive breakdown of the manufacturing costs of the super-site revealing the M&J machine would cost $58M. 6000 tonnes of short-cut bico. reinforcing fibre would be needed at an assumed price of $2/kg. The pulp would cost 55c/kg and the superabsorbent (45,000 tonnes/year) would cost $2/kg.

The Regulation of Anti-microbials in Europe by Mike Baldry of MGCB Associates


He reviewed the changes to be expected when the harmonised system replaces a plethora of national regulations.

The new Biocidal Products Directive (BPD), published on April 24 th 1998 is now in force and has to be adopted into the laws of European states by May 13 th 2000. It introduces a 2-layer approval system based on risk assessment for the many active substances and biocidal products which are outside the regulations for chemicals, human and veterinary medicines, medical devices, cosmetics, food, food-contacting materials and plant protection products.

There are many uncertainties for manufacturers and users, however:

  • Biocides used simply to protect a product from microbial attack will be exempt.
    Biocides intended to sanitise surfaces will need BPD approval.
  • The BPD will reduce incentives to research new biocides and their uses.
  • There will be higher costs for data generation, fees and manpower to comply with the directive.
  • There will be higher barriers to entering or remaining in the anti-microbials business in Europe.
  • The Biocides business is likely to become concentrated among the larger companies.
  • Biocides businesses will be similar to agro-chemicals and pesticides businesses.
  • Results from risk assessments under the BPD could affect similar products in other regions of the world.
  • The BPD will represent a much higher hurdle to obtaining regulatory approval than FDA/EPA.
  • The BPD could prove to be a deterrent to imports, and for those products with approval, an incentive to export into regions with lower regulatory barriers. (e.g. Approval in the USA would be cheaper to obtain for BPD approved products)

Roy Broughton of Auburn University on Textiles with Antimicrobial Functionality.


He concluded that the ideal textile anti-microbial - one which kills all microbes which come into contact with it, while being non-toxic to higher life forms and not persistent in the textile-waste environment, does not exist. Developing the ideal is getting increasingly costly thanks to ever tightening regulations.

  • Triclosan, is now widely used in fibres from Hoechst Celanese (acetate), Synthetic Industries (olefin) and Sterling Fibres (acrylic), but is now thought to be resulting in triclosan-resistant bacteria.
  • Biguanides from Zeneca were reported to be available in cellulosic fibres from Acordis® (sic)

    With regard to whether the biocide should be spun-in fibres or added topically to fabrics he commented that it depended on the rate of leaching in the application. (Fast leachers better within the fibre, slow leachers better applied topically)

Saul Schapiro of Textile Biocides Inc. on Dealing with Current EPA regulations.


You can apply for registration by the EPA, but:

  • It will take at least 9 months.
  • The EPA has no protocol for the registration of treated textiles.
  • Much expense, patience and persistence needed to succeed.
  • Have to demonstrate that your product is effective at the 99.9% kill standard. However he commented that this could be relaxed in the interests of assisting the control of current "problem" organisms such as E.Coli, Staph., and Strep., for instance, on cutting boards.
  • AATCC method 100 proves acceptable to the EPA, method 147 does not.
  • Test data has to be from a GLP certified laboratory.
  • There have not been many successful registrations due to the instability of the EPA positions.

You can apply for exemption from the regulations if:

  • The biocide is only to protect the product and,
  • If you imply no benefits to the user.

This exemption route could be a good start, allowing you to market the product while persisting with full registration or "waiting for the law to change!". (A four-page document clarifying the "Treated Articles Exemption" is available appended to the paper.) With regard to terminology, "Antibacterial" is no-longer allowed in a non-public health context, an while "Antimicrobial" is OK, it must be qualified by a statement of what it is active against. For example the FTC are currently "going after" Vaseline Intensive Care Antibacterial Hand Lotion. "Unqualified anti-microbial/bacterial claims will not be tolerated".

Confusion regarding the jurisdiction of the FDA and the EPA is now being sorted out:

  • EPA are dealing with cutting-boards, toothbrushes etc.
  • FDA are dealing with mattress covers in hospitals (but not domestic?)

Processing and Property Studies of Cotton-surfaced nonwovens by Christine Sun of Tandec


She described a Cotton Inc. sponsored project on stretching spunbonds to which PP/cotton blend webs had been thermally bonded. The bonded webs had been stretched to 1.4, 1.5 and 1.7 times their original length, the most notable effect being an almost proportionate increase in thickness and basis weight.

In response to questions she admitted that they had been allowed to shrink in the CD. The other conclusions were therefore less valuable.

"Carding of Microfibres" by Abdelfattah Seyman of NCSU


presented data on processing Wellman's 0.9 dtex polyester on a conventional flat-top card.

The neatly designed and statistically analysed experiments showed that nep and broken fibre levels in card-web could be reduced to acceptable levels by increasing drafting, minimising the fibre recycling (by reducing the doffer/cylinder setting) reducing the feed-roll speed (i.e. throughput), and reducing the fibre length (38 to 30mm). Unfortunately, web uniformity tended to deteriorate, and the only suggestions for improving this were to use a highly opened fibre, and to pay more attention to feed-lap uniformity.

An old textile hand in the audience commented that he used to process 9-10 micron cotton into 120's CC yarns, but only on cards with flexible wire clothing. Clearly many more carding points than were available on modern metallic wire (saw-tooth) clothing were necessary for microfibres.

Thermal Bonding Session


This ran concurrently with the air-laid nonwoven session and was not attended. The papers were as follows:

Doing It With Hot Air by Don B. Gillespie, Fleissner, Inc.


Although bonding is not the only influencing factor in creating a nonwoven product, it is the key element providing strength and performance to a nonwoven. Compared to other bonding processes, thermal bonding provides manufacturers with numerous benefits ranging from economic efficiency to uniformity. (paper absent from the proceedings)

Continuous Ultrasonic Bonding by Frank Simonetti, Herrmann Ultrasonics


The latest technology of continuous high speed ultrasonic welding for nonwovens. This session covered the facts and fictions of ultrasonic bonding and its relationship to other thermal bonding processes.

Heat Generation During Ultrasonic Bonding by Z. Mao & B.C. Goswami, Clemson University


A method for the prediction of heat generation during ultrasonic bonding and its effects on fabric properties.

Nonwovens from Cotton/Cellulose Acetate Blends by Kermit E. Duckett, UTK.


Continued interest in biodegradable/compostable nonwovens has led to the production and evaluation ofproducts containing cotton/ cellulose acetate fibers. By modifying the bonding process suitable fabrics can be produced.

The printed paper indicates that acetone vapour treatment, and aqueous acetone padding prior to calendering improve the strength of the nonwoven, but not as much as triacetin.

CRW 30/9/99

Thursday, 5 November 1998

Insight 98 Conference


  • Current spun-lace production worldwide was put at 150,000 tonnes from 97 lines (by Phillipe Coppin Consulting). Capacity is nearer 250,000. He mentioned CLY as a new fibre to watch and said it was now used commercially by Dupont and Nisshinbo. New players in HE include Albad (Israel), Norafin, Hildener Filz, +1 more (Germany), Novita, Graboplast,+1 more (Poland), Alpha, Nouva FNT (Italy), Fukuyo, Omikenshi, Kinsei Seishi, Ikeda Shigyo in Japan, Hangzhou Xinhua Paper, Henan Zhengzhou, and Hefei Sanitary in China, Sheng-Hung in Taiwan, DHJ in Malaysia, and Schweitzer Mauduit in the USA (K-C subsidiary).
  • Europe now has 10 low pressure HE lines dedicated to creating a bonded surface on bulky cosmetic wipes. Only 3 of the companies involved could be named, P&G (France), Rauscher ( Germany) and Sanitars ( Italy).
  • The new versatile air-laid line now being started up byAir-Formed Composites has product objectives including several with rayon-pulp blends. Burlap replacement for plant root protection was one of them. One wound dressing featured a calcium alginate fibre top layer over an active carbon/pulp blend.
  • Ason Engineering has now sold 3 fine denier bico spun bond lines . Akzo Nobel are taking delivery of one for polyester, American Nonwovens are taking another. The pilot scale roll goods on display were incredibly soft. Polylactic acid was among the polymers they were designing for (see below)
  • John Starr described the nonwovens business ($9billion global sales at roll goods level) as a medium sized industry with modest growth potential (3-6% pa in developed countries, 10-15% pa in developing countries). At the converted products level, the global value is $36billion dollars. These figures exclude waddings (250,000 tonnes USA) and wet-laid glass (300,000 tonnes in North America). Spun-Melt lines now make 400,000 tonnes of nonwoven in the USA and still grow at 6% pa. Spun lace and air-laid are growing at 7% pa. Industrial wipes at 6% were one of the highest growth end-uses.
  • 3M have developed melt additives which can permanently alter the wettability of polyolefins. The specially designed molecules feature a fluorocarbon head enabling them to migrate to the surface within 2 days of manufacture. The hydrocarbon tail acts as a bonded-in root. FC/hydrocarbon molecules give more hydrophobicity and stain repellance, but if the molecule is in three parts with a highly hydrophilic body between head and tail, the FC head drags this to the surface resulting in increased hydrophilicity. The molecular model illustrating this had a sulphur molecule under the FC head. The migration process does not occur in polyester or polyamide.
  • Jim Hanson (MTS)said there were now 2 air-lay lines under construction to make diaper core. Both were 80-100,000 tonne capacity and were expected to make products with more SAP than pulp. Rayonier is believed to be buying one, and Buckeye the other.
  • SAP can now be bought for 67c/lb on major contracts. Truckloads are available at 85c/lb.
  • Superabsorbent fibres are still expected to figure in the next generation of cores due to the simplicity of airlaying them at high concentrations.
  • Rayonier introduced NovaThin , a preformed diaper core made from a compressed blend of “special” pulp fibres and between 20 and 55% SAP. The density was between 0.3 and 0.45 gms/cc (i.e close to tampon density) and the final product was one-fifth of the thickness of current ultrathin diaper cores. The special pulp fibre had been developed for resilience and were said to be a mercerised high-purity chemical pulp. In private conversation they did not disagree with the suggestion that they were moistening the SAP prior to hot calendaring so that it could bond the structure in its compressed state. They also indicated that they would avoid working with P&G or KC because both had proved troublesome customers for their fluffing pulp.
  • The work on biodegradable plastics continues and “green” marketing issues are expected to return to centre-stage. The oil based routes to polycaprolactone (Solvay, Novamont and Union Carbide), and to biodegradable copolyesters (Dupont, Bayer and Eastman) are still being developed but are likely to prove too expensive. The smart money is on the annual-crop routes to polylactic acid (Now <$2/lb from Mitsui, and Dow-Cargill have a plant under construction) and polyhydroxybutyrate. Genetic engineering is now enabling lab. production of the polymers in the corn or soya seeds and industrial processes using this technology can be expected to be operational industrially within 5 years.
  • Trutona introduced a range of flushable sanpro using a water soluble PVOH backsheet, a lightly entangled viscose topsheet, and a CMC superabsorbent. It was a premium product targeting the new and growing environmentally responsible supermarket chains such as “Whole Foods” and “Wild Oats”. The products were said to be made in the UK by a (or the) Hospital Specialities Company. The same principle was being developed 10 years ago for flushable diapers – which apparently proved too large for the sewage system, and worked far less well than the market leaders. Their next introduction would be certified-organic cotton tampons because they felt there was a perception of greater TSS risks with rayon or rayon blends.
  • Cotton Incorporated gave a paper on the use of linters as an additive to pulp in diaper cores. It was a thorough piece of work with much data provided by MTS. At no point did any performance benefit likely to justify a premium price emerge. However a “Now contains cotton” label on a diaper pack might just attract custom.
  • USDA gave a paper on the use of fibre extracted from chicken feathers in nonwovens and composites. Apparently 2 billion kgs of feathers are produced annually in the USA, and half of this weight can be extracted in the form of surprisingly uniform 5 micron fibres about 1cm long. “Several” licencees are now working on hundredfold scale-up of the currently 50kg/hr extraction process.

Tuesday, 30 June 1998

Nonwovens Technology Conference - Berlin 27-29th June 98


Coming immediately after IDEA 98 this meeting underlined the growing importance of air-lay HE technology. In the battle between HE and Air-laid for the baby wipe market all parties have realised that combining the two makes sense:


Guy Goldstein of Fort James ( Europe ) reviewed advances in air-laid technology:• Dan-web claiming 30mm fibre length capability but in reality they now handle 12mm routinely.
• M and J claiming 6-10mm.
• Fibre Visions (The merged Hercules/Danaklon fibre business) now cutting to 3mm on line to allow M&J machine owners to make thermal bonded air-laid.

Joseph Bevquila of Woodbridge Foams :
• He introduced a superabsorbent-containing polyurethane foam intended to replace the wood-pulp/SAP mixtures now used.
• He envisaged pre-formed "pancakes" of the absorbent foam being incorporated into diapers and femcare.
• Simple structure-less raw material wastage.
• Faster line speeds.
• Higher acquisition speeds, better fluid distribution, drier surface.
• Soft, conformable, garment-like fit.
• Better core resilience, can be compressed highly in packing with full recovery, no stability issues when wet,
• Enables new low-cost diaper machines to be designed.
• Cheaper, more absorbent non X-linked SAP's can be used because the foam acts as a protective shell against compression.
• Foam can be thermally formed or embossed to give full control of fluid wicking.

Costs were not discussed, but it was clear that several major companies were taking this very seriously. If viable it will alter the prospects for SAP fibres and result in new coverstock designs.

Dr. Bernice Krafchik (Hospitals for Sick Children)
• Predicts that coverstocks will be developed containing moisturisers which will protect the skin before it gets wet.
• She preferred petrolatum to aloe, based on it's long history of safe use on infant skin.

Dr Deborah Lickfield of PGI Nonwovens on Medical Nonwovens:
• Wet-laid sterile wrap still predominates but SMS is gaining despite higher price.
• SMS has proven to be the better product, but many buyers still feel that the wet-laid is good enough.
• European sterilising temperatures are getting higher than US due desire to kill CJD prions. Now 136C is used which is too high for the polyolefins.
• Gowns sold pre-sterilised so the main issue is the system used by the bulk steriliser.
• Polyolefin is no good in Cobalt 60 irradiation. K-C use ETO for pre-sterilising because all their gowns are PP.
• Cellulose is no good in peroxide plasma because it retains the peroxide.
• Hospitals don't care what bulk sterilizer is used so long as sterility is guaranteed.
• K-C, Dupont and Dexter dominate the sector with about 25% each. Sontara preferred to SMS generally, but Dexter's wet-laid is favourite in drapes, one of the largest sectors.
• Table Covers are like gown fabric but can be weaker due to absence of seams. Wet laid still good here, with sterilisation depending on the distributor.
• Masks are SMS, meltblown or tissue.
• Wound care is dominated by PGI.

Key Issues for New Product Design:• Transmission of disease to health workers: Aids, hepatitis exposure running at 6 per 100 full-time years.
• TB, and other highly antibiotic resistant bacteria with transmission through droplets in coughs and sneezes now causing concern.
• Old concerns about protecting patient from contamination from OR team and theatre have been replaced by new concerns to protect OR team from contaminated patient.
• Environmental: 50% of OR waste is from disposables, land-filling getting more difficult, handling of contaminated fabrics a problem.
• Regulations: FDA, GMP in USA ; CE Mark in Europe .
• Cost containment: impact of HMO's in the USA , expiry of KC's SMS patents allowing many new entries, reusables improving through use of new washing and refinishing techniques.
• Ageing baby boomers reach retirement - massive surge in the OAP group expected. Incontinence is a common problem.
• Changes in procedures: less invasive procedures, shorter hospital stays, average patient is now more "acute", hospital workers need more protection.
• Sterile wrap needs most strength. (if its good enough for a gown it will work as a drape but not necessarily as a wrap.)
• Barrier performance: is it fluid proof or fluid resistant. Can it resist 3 micron particles?
• Sterilisation stability, comfort, breathability, linting

Recent developments:• New meltblowns with finer fibres, electreted for filter efficiency . KC, PGI and BBA have them. AKZO said to have added this to the range in 1995.
• Gowns that dissolve in the wash water (OREX)
• Biodegradable PP ( Oji Paper )
• PGI, Dupont, KC, Fama Jersey all with new HE fabrics. (Dupont COMFORMAX ULTRA, a 100%PET HE gown fabric coated with Teflon said to washable 6 times.)

Ken Lowe, Consultant, on Fluff Pulp Markets:


• Fluff pulp in US diapers peaked in 86 at 900,000 tonnes, with 50 g/diaper.

• It halved by 1996 and is heading for 300000 by 2006. However worldwide usage is stable.

• Of 18.6 million tonnes of softwood pulp and 16 million tonnes of hardwood pulp, fluff only accounts for 18% of the softwood pulp.

• SCA have 80,000 tonnes of BCTMP as well as Metsa Sirla's 110000 tonnes.

• Diaper pulp is 75% of total fluff usage.

Scott Sneed, ex P&G and KC

• The main theme of his talk related to addressing the "wellness" megatrend in marketing new products. e.g. Any skin contact product using aloe vera or vitamin E sells.

• He liked the creative marketing of new products as exemplified by selling modal viscose fibre in night-dresses as "a fibre made from beech-wood with conductive properties ... low static... good night's sleep.

Odile Primel of Rhovyl on Rhovyl chlorofibres:


• They were made by dry-spinning PVC from a CS2/acetone solvent mixture. Rhone Poulenc are the only producers. They make 4000 tpy now, but have an 8000 tonne capacity.

• Blends of PVC and chlorinated PVC are sold as FR fibres. The chlorinated PVC has 60% chlorine, or roughly 0.75 chlorine atoms per carbon atom.

• Copolymer with EVA is sold as heat sealable fibre for tea-bags. N.B . JR Crompton is looking for a second source.)

• They have now introduced Rhovl AS antibacterial fibre for underwear, socks (30% blend with cotton), bedding (duvets and pillows), hospital textiles (including dressings), filters.

• Dope route using triclosan - "in-depth treatment" is preferred to topical or grafting approach.

• There is only one European standard for efficacy of antimicrobials: Swiss standard SNV 195 920 for antimicrobial textiles. Rhovyl AS certified as "permanent" because it survives 200 (30 C!) washes. (Literature available)

Michael Wehmann of J&M Labs. GMBH on the latest melt-blowing technology for polymers and adhesives.


• 1 gsm of glue can be meltblown to allow soft, breathable laminates to be made.

• SAMAS (Spunbond, Adhesive, Meltblown) therefore outperforms thermally laminated SMS in some applications.

• Melt blown energy costs are reducing dramatically - blowers at 1 bar air pressure now used instead of compressors: 1-2 kwh per kilo now, i.e very similar to spun bond.

Anders Moller on the ASON spunbonding process


• It is now capable of making 0.5 dtex filaments from both PP and PET.

• To compete with the surface area of SMS spunbond has to be around 1 denier.

• They can also make side-by-side bicomponent spun bond using differing MFI polymers to get crimped filaments and bulkier fabrics.

• On normal deniers, wind up speeds of 600 metres/min. are possible, at 0.5den, 100 metres/min is more likely. Filament velocity in the slot attenuator is reaching 5600m/min at 0.5denier.

Dennis Sens of Tartas on Speciality Pulps for Air Laid:


• Tartas operate a sulphite process on maritime pine and separate roundwood and sawmill waste to make pulp fibres with different length to diameter ratio.

• The younger roundwood fibres are ribbon-like and give the best softness/strength balance.

• Sawmill waste pulp gives bulkier, rougher, more absorbent fabrics.

• Tartas are now developing pulps especially for for air-laid HE processes.

• He estimated the air-laid market at 288,000 tonnes/year, growing at 10% per year. (c.f. Jim Hansen's 30%)

• Latex bonded has 70% share, wipes are the main market (43%), with hygiene (20%) and Tableware (17%).

• Fluff pulps are a pulp industry speciality, only just 10% of pulp market, and only 6% of this is used in air-laid fabrics.

Ivan Pivko of Nota Bene on new air-laids:


He was CEO of Merfin before the hostile Buckeye takeover. His paper reviewed the 30 years of air-laid development.

• K-C attempted to commercialise the Kroyer process in 1967 for "Softique" tissues, failed due to high costs.

• 1977 saw American Can launch "Bolt" kitchen wipes. Again failure, but more slowly.

• The technologically attractive theme of making a better paper by dry papermaking proved to be a blind alley.

• The true value of air-laid is now in nonwovens, not papers.

• The industry needs a tailor made cellulose (pulp) fibre, better bicomponent polyolefins, latex designed for "finishing" a thermal bonded product (not bonding it) and superabsorbent fibres.

• He predicts machines 3 times the size of todays biggest will be made to enter the pre-formed absorbent core business.

• He also expects air-laid HE nonwovens to allow the incorporation of pulp into many more nonwoven products. (Threat to viscose and CLY)

Dieter Muller of Bremen University on Carding;


• Coverstock production speeds are moving up from 200m/min on the latest Spinnbau cards.

• He expects 400 m/min by 2010, after radical redesign.

• Widths will be limited to around 4 metres at these high speeds by flexing of the small worker rolls which at 4 metres will have to be made of carbon fibre composites.

• Air resistance problems will be overcome using permeable belts allowing the webs to be sucked onto them.

• Higher speeds easier on parallel webs than random.

• He predicts air-lay principles will be incorporated in cards to get higher productivity.

• He predicts increased use of natural fibres in composites to replace plastics.

• Mercedes and others now using epoxy-bonded and PP bonded flax instead of plastics in car interiors.

• PVA-bonded and starch-bonded are coming next to get total biodegradability. (N.B. the German Aerospace Establishment are working with CLY in this area.)

Dr Munstermann of Fleissner on Aquajet:


• He showed photos of their 4.2 metre HE injectors built for a new European installation. (Could only be the Dupont Asturias line?)

• Lines now available at this width with maximum pressure of 300 bar, max. speed 250 metres/min, max. vacuum 0.3 bar, max water jet velocity 230m/s.

• Web production rate is still the limit on productivity.

• They use a three stage HE system (two drums and one conveyor) for weights up to 150 gsm.

• Conveyor gives much better dewatering and saves money (c.f. CEL system)

• They have a 5 stage system for 400gsm products - 4 drums and one conveyor. However this machine is also very good for lightweights.

• They now have Trutzschler opening, Spinnbau carding, Dan Web air-lay, 5 stage HE and TAD in one pilot plant for customer development. (Maybe not all in line).

• Claimed to have done much work with Lyocell for Lenzing .

• Graphs produced comparing LL and PES. LL gives same strength as PES and half the extension.

• 100% PES at 180 gsm gives 500N MD at 70% breaking extension.

• 1000N in both MD and CD possible at 350 gsm.

• Can go to 500 gsm with coarser fibres, all the above being with 1.7dtex.

• HE of spunlaid 4dtex PES at 148 gsm gives excellent results at pressures above about 180 bar.

• Spunlaid lines go faster than carding so he sees good prospects here for HE in future.

• Fleissner v Courtaulds question: F better with 400 bar, 4.2 metre width, sturdy but light drums, better dewatering systems.

Jim Hanson of MTS on Thin Diapers:


• Why? Shipping economics, production economics, consumer appeal.

• Half the thickness of the current thin diapers is now possible.

• Key problems are core integrity with high levels of SAP, liquid spreading, acquisition rate, shape changes to get good fit.

• He expects foam/sap cores to make progress, especially if the foam can be blown from precursors on-site by the diaper producer to minimise foam shipping costs.

• He also expects roll-goods technologies to be further developed as cores. These designs are pulpless and based on combinations of nonwoven technologies: CDA's prevent further disclosure at this stage.

• Tissue/SAP is another possibility which ought to move ahead.

• He puts the 00/01 air-laid capacity to be 450,000 tonnes i.e 33% per year growth in vendor technology alone.

• KC and P&G would probably build their own new lines and and would add to this.

• Not linear growth though, just a few big steps.

• Expects SAP fibres to have a major roll to play.